‘The fire made us fearless’: New York Middle Church’s material resurrection

Rev. Jacqueline J. Lewis, the senior minister of Middle Collegiate Church, was emotional as she stepped up to the pulpit on Easter Sunday. This marked the congregation’s first gathering in their own building since a fire in December 2020 had destroyed their historic 128-year-old church.

Lewis expressed her joy at the congregation’s presence on this significant day, highlighting the church’s resurrection from the ashes of the devastating fire. Nearly 200 people attended the Easter worship service, led by Middle’s choir, to celebrate Christ’s resurrection and the church’s revival.

Discussing the challenges faced during the years following the fire, Lewis emphasized the importance of community and hope. The congregation had to adapt during renovations and find temporary spaces for worship, showcasing their resilience and unity.

After the fire gutted their church, Middle Collegiate Church’s leadership worked to incorporate the surviving elements of the original building into a new sanctuary. The demolition of damaged walls freed up funds for the renovation, resulting in a newly repurposed worship space that can accommodate 225 people.

Lewis highlighted the congregation’s commitment to social justice work in their neighborhood, including initiatives supporting LGBTQ+ individuals and organizing #BlackLivesMatter rallies. The church has launched a new nonprofit, Freedom Rising Inc., dedicated to social justice and the arts.

As the church reopens, Lewis emphasized the community’s sense of fearlessness and urgency in pursuing their mission. The church’s bell, which survived the fire, has been reinstated in a glass case in the lobby, symbolizing the congregation’s resilience and faith.

The congregation looks forward to a bright future as they continue their legacy of social justice and community engagement. Lewis expressed gratitude for the support and emphasized the importance of trustworthy coverage of religion in today’s rapidly changing world.