The Best Olive Oil Subscriptions (2025)

Bon Appétit’s editors independently select all products featured on their platform, but they may receive compensation from retailers or through links within their articles.

Being someone who frequently writes about food-related products, my pantry is filled to the brim with various items. I have more types of vinegar than I can count, an excessive amount of bone broth, and an overflow of spices tucked away in the back of my cupboard, long past their prime. However, one pantry essential that I never complain about having in surplus is olive oil. It ranks high alongside kosher salt as one of the most commonly used ingredients in my kitchen. I use it for cooking dinner every evening, in the salad dressings I prepare for work, and in citrus-flavored snacking cakes. I even drizzle the finest olive oil over vanilla ice cream at times (a must-try if you haven’t already).

For olive oil enthusiasts like myself, running out of this essential while in the middle of cooking is a nightmare. The best way to avoid such a scenario is by subscribing to an olive oil delivery service. Not only can you potentially save some money off the regular price, but more importantly, you can ensure you always have a fresh and delicious supply of oil on hand for all your culinary needs.

To help you decide which olive oil subscription is right for you, we have reviewed a variety of options from different brands:

– Wonder Valley: Offers subscriptions for their classic Olive Oil or limited-edition Olio Nuevo.
– Corto: Provides a Truly Extra Virgin Olive Oil subscription with various packaging options.
– Flamingo Estate: Features a Heritage Extra Virgin Olive Oil and a limited-edition Garlic Olive Oil for subscription.
– Brightland: Offers a subscription for their best-selling oil duo, Awake and Alive.
– California Olive Ranch: Provides a 100% California Subscription option.
– Kosterina: Offers an Original Extra Virgin Olive Oil and an Organic Everyday Extra Virgin Olive Oil subscription.
– Pompeian: Includes the Organic Robust and Smooth Extra Virgin Olive Oil for subscription.
– Enzo’s Table: Offers a variety of olive oils in different intensity levels for subscription.

When selecting an olive oil subscription, it is essential to look for clear harvest date information, as well as consider factors like flexibility in quantities and frequencies. Proper storage of olive oil in a dark place away from light and heat is crucial to maintain its freshness. Once opened, olive oil should ideally be used within three to six months for the best quality.

For more shopping recommendations and culinary inspiration, check out our other articles on the best kitchen tools and cookbooks for a vibrant dining experience.