Ex-Yankees Prospect’s Debut Should Make Team Regret Ever Trading Him

Aaliyan Mohammed, a sports writer for Newsweek based in Atlanta, GA, focuses on MLB content. He joined Newsweek in 2024 after working at MLB.com, Wisconsin Sports Heroics, and Heavy.com. A graduate of Mississippi State University, you can contact Aaliyan at a.mohammed@newsweek.com.

The New York Yankees pulled off a major trade this offseason, acquiring Devin Williams from the Milwaukee Brewers by sending Nestor Cortes and Caleb Durbin, a prospect at the time. Durbin recently debuted for the Brewers at third base, addressing the Yankees’ struggles at that position. While Williams has been inconsistent, Durbin impressed in his debut, showcasing skills that could benefit the Yankees.

In his first MLB game against the Athletics at American Family Field on April 18, 2025, Caleb Durbin of the Milwaukee Brewers went 2-for-3 and narrowly missed hitting a home run. He displayed his abilities by making a remarkable catch and showing off his speed with an infield single and smart baserunning.

On the other hand, Devin Williams has struggled with a 5.14 ERA this season, conceding more runs than in the previous year. Despite playing just one game, Durbin has excelled in Triple-A for the Brewers, breaking stolen base records in the Arizona Fall League and showcasing his speed and defensive prowess at third base.

Durbin’s potential impact for the Brewers is evident, and if he continues to perform well, the Yankees might regret trading him, especially if DJ LeMahieu falters upon his return. Still in the early stages of his contract, Durbin could become a valuable asset for the Brewers. The Yankees, on the other hand, might seek a third baseman before the trade deadline.

Fans in Atlanta were surprised to see the former Yankees player lead off for their team in his debut game.